A Retrospective of Two Vintages – R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 1996 vs 2012 by TheChampagneSommelier. [ read the full champagne story ]
Estimated reading time: 11 minutes
“Every bottle tells a story, what is yours?”
TheChampagneSommelier
R&L Legras ’Cuvée Saint-Vincent’: The Pure Soul of Chouilly
Let us pause for a moment and contemplate the concept of perfection. In the world of champagne, it is a dangerous word, a word I rarely use. But if there is a place where the pursuit of the pure, unadulterated Chardonnay grape’s true expression approaches fulfillment, it is in the holy Grand Cru village of Chouilly.
And in Chouilly, there is a family, a house, that more than any other has made this village’s distinctive terroir its life’s mission. I am, of course, speaking of R&L Legras. Today, we will not speak of their brilliant non-vintage, which in itself is a reference point. We are going deeper. We are going to speak of their crown jewel. A champagne that carries not only the soul of the village but also the name of the patron saint of wine growers. We are going to speak of Cuvée Saint-Vincent.
The House: Chouilly’s Undisputed Masters
R&L Legras, now under the dynamic leadership of Julien Barbier (sixth generation), is not a house that shouts the loudest. They are the opposite. They are that quiet, self-assured master in the room whose judgment everyone trusts. While other houses blend grapes from dozens of villages to achieve a ’house style’, Legras has chosen a different path: to be the absolute specialist in Chouilly.
They are technically a Négociant-Manipulant (NM), but they act in heart and soul like a grower (RM). They own 25 hectares of the finest sites in the village and supplement with grapes from friends and neighbors exclusively in Chouilly. They breathe this terroir. It is no coincidence that Legras has for decades been the secret of sommeliers and a pillar on the wine lists of the world’s foremost three-star Michelin restaurants.
Old Monsieur Barbier, Julien’s father, loved to visit top French restaurants. His relationship with top sommeliers has ensured that their entry-level champagne is listed at every single French three-star restaurant. A record in itself. They deliver an unimpeachable, laser-focused purity, vintage after vintage.
The Terroir: The Quintessence of Chouilly
To understand Saint-Vincent, one must understand Chouilly. As the northernmost village in the Côte des Blancs, it has a unique character. Certainly, everything rests on the deep, ancient Campanian chalk, just like its neighbors Le Mesnil and Cramant. But here, the topsoil is often slightly deeper and richer.
The result? Chouilly is the generous Grand Cru village. It (usually) lacks the almost brutal, ascetic austerity of a young Le Mesnil. Instead, it offers a more prominent, ripe citrus fruit, a more voluptuous body, and an almost irresistible charm of white flowers (acacia, honeysuckle) and white peach. But make no mistake—beneath this voluptuous charm lies a backbone of steel, a vibrating acidity, and a minerality so salty that one can sense the ocean.
The Wine: Cuvée Saint-Vincent
So, to the wine itself. ’Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ is a tribute to the patron saint of wine growers, and it is Legras’ tête de cuvée. This champagne is anything but a rushed product.
- Origin: 100% Chardonnay from 100% Grand Cru Chouilly.
- Vintage: This is always a vintage champagne, made only in years when Julien Barbier considers the harvest to have the depth, structure, and aging potential required.
- Selection: The grapes come from the house’s oldest and best-exposed vineyard plots, often with vines that are over 40 years old.
- Vinification: The wine is vinified exclusively in stainless steel tanks. Legras are masters of steel—they do not chase oak character, they chase terroir. They want the purest, most unfiltered interpretation of the chalk.
- Aging: After bottling, the wine rests for at least 8 to 10 years on its lees in the cool, dark chalk cellars. This is where the magic happens.
Gastronomic Potential
This is not a champagne for a loud aperitif. This is a champagne that demands contemplation and, above all, food of the same caliber. Drinking this on its own is an experience, but pairing it with the right food is to reach a higher gastronomic level.
Think Turbot with browned butter, horseradish, and trout roe. Think Lobster Thermidor or Grilled Langoustine with langoustine foam à la Mannerström. It even handles light meats; a Sweetbread with morels is a sensational combination.
Final Verdict
R&L Legras ’Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ is, without hesitation, one of the absolute foremost Blanc de Blancs produced today. It is a reference wine for Chouilly, a master class in how to balance maturity with freshness, richness with austerity. This is a wine that proves that transparency and purity are the most powerful tools a winemaker has.
A bottle for those special moments when only the best is good enough. Cheers to the pure chalk!
A Whisper of Chouilly
TheChampagneSommelier inspired by Tomas Tranströmer [Autumn ’25]
From Chouilly’s chalk, the silent, white truth, a signal rises. Not a shout, but a crystal clear echo.
Here, where the soil is thin and the light sharper, Chardonnay has found its most isolated expression.
–
Cuvée Saint-Vincent, a naked idea.
A mirror turned toward the sky, toward the brief sun.
–
It is no made-up story, just pure, mineral silence.
Every bubble is a breath from a bygone, cold day.
–
The wine carries the patience from Legras’ cellar vaults.
A waiting that is not longing, but a state of being.
–
The taste is like a sudden, sharp memory of a railway station at dawn, empty and clear.
There is an electric tension in its salinity.
–
This is the wine that knows about the white wall, about the heavy sleep deep underground.
When the glass is lowered, a transparency lingers.
–
A feeling of having seen something secret, momentary.
A fleeting glimpse into the geometry of the limestone.
–
And the world outside, it continues, heavy and dark.
But in here, in Saint-Vincent, everything is put right.
2012 R&L Legras ’Cuvée Saint-Vincent’
Chouilly
95 points
100CH
[Market value approx. €150]
Tasting note TheChampagneSommelier – Pouring this wine is a visual delight. The color is a clear, brilliant golden yellow hue with an endless stream of microscopically small, dancing bubbles. The scent is a symphony of maturity and precision. The first thing that strikes me is that unmistakable scent of chalk dust—like striking two flint stones against each other. But behind that, a world unfolds: ripe lemon glaze, candied lemon peel, white peach, beeswax, and a deep, autolytic character of toasted brioche, hazelnuts, and almond paste. It is complex, but at the same time so incredibly pure. In the mouth… this is texture. The mousse is creamy like a soufflé, but the second it lands on the tongue, a razor-sharp, citrus-driven acidity cuts straight through and cleanses the palate. It is the perfect balance between Chouilly’s generosity and the chalk’s austere minerality. The taste is deep and intense. I find notes of lemon curd, baked apples, a light smokiness, and a salinity that almost reminds one of oyster shells. It is a wine that fills the entire mouth without ever becoming heavy. The finish is, as expected, endless. It lingers for minutes, vibrating with energy, and leaves behind a clean, salty, mineral feeling that makes the mouth water.
2012 Vintage Report
★★★★
- Harvest: September 10
- Total Sales: 308,599,509 bottles
- Yield: 9,210 kg/ha
- France: 171,250,077 bottles
- Vineyard Area: 33,578 ha
- Export: 137,349,432 bottles
- Average potential alcohol: 10.6 %
- Price: €5.73/kg
- Average total acidity: 7.8 g/l
- Average gluconic acid: 0.01 g/l
Overview: From the worst to the best 2012 offered difficult conditions at the start of the year, but the growers’ fate changed completely after flowering and produced fantastic results. After a mild January, temperatures in February reached -10°C several times and went as cold as -20°C, although there was little permanent damage to the vines. March was warm and bud break came early. April was rainy and May brought frost, damaging between 10% and 17% of the vineyard in various sub-regions. The rain continued right up to flowering, setting a twenty-year record and bringing mildew.
Fortunately for the growers, the rain stopped in mid-July, and there was almost no more until the harvest was completed. From this period, sunny and warm conditions began, with temperatures rising to heatwave levels in mid-August, which dried out the grapes thoroughly. Despite the frost damage and pressure from mildew, 2012 is a particularly successful year and one whose top wines can be stored for decades of aging.
– According to Champagne Club by Richard Juhlin
1996 R&L Legras ’Cuvée Saint-Vincent Vinothèque’
Chouilly
97 points
100CH
[Market value approx. €400]
Tasting note TheChampagneSommelier – My relationship with this particular vintage of Saint-Vincent is strong. I participated in a tasting with the 35 greatest 96s about ten years ago (published in issue 85 of Livets Goda)… When the result was revealed from the blind tasting, most were in shock that Saint-Vincent had wiped the floor with many of the big guns. Only beaten by Krug ’Clos du Mesnil’ and Bollinger VVF! Last spring, before a dinner on the way to Le Dame de Pic, Ann-Sophie Pic’s one-star restaurant on 20 Rue de Louvre in Paris, I was served this legend blindly in a spring-warm Jardin de Tuileries. Such beautiful textbook champagne! Like old Salon! Developed aromas in combination with mountain stream purity and freshness in the light sunshine of the Paris spring.
1996 R&L Legras Cuvée Saint-Vincent. A name that evokes not only respect but also a certain intellectual nostalgia. Especially for me, as my relationship to this very bottle is inscribed in memory with almost cinematic precision. What did I meet? A blanc de blancs from a vintage known for its piercing acidity and its almost brutal, ascetic structure. It is not a 1996 for those who prefer their Champagnes soft and accommodating ; this is for masochists with a wallet. From the start, this legend was very promising and focused with a more toasted style than usual. Tough acidity. Very broad and fine on magnum with an added creaminess. Always age Legras wines for at least 15 years. In Saint-Vincent’s case, wait at least 20 years. Fantastic development and one of the truly great 96s.
The color is deeply golden, a testimony that it has received the respect of time it deserves. The bubbles are razor-sharp, a fine, relentless stream that despite its age insists on reminding you why 1996 is 1996. The nose, ladies and gentlemen, is where the wine begins its subtle deception. It has that classic Grand Cru Chardonnay profile from Côte des Blancs, but with a twis. One is met by toasted bread, butterscotch, and an unmistakable note of salinity and chalk minerality. But then it comes: an almost incredible lemon zest acidity that has transformed into something purely scherzo-like and energy-filled. It is as if the wine has not aged, but rather has distilled its youth into a concentrated essence1.
In the mouth, it is perfectly linear, a straight, austere line that seems to stretch toward eternity. The acidity is monumental, but not in an aggressive way, but rather like the backbone of a perfectly built house. It cuts through the palate and leaves behind an explosive, almost ethereal minerality. It is pure, bone-dry, and incredibly focused. To drink this 1996 is to understand the beauty of patience. It was one of the few times I silently admitted that the wine, in that Parisian garden, had outsmarted me. I knew it was good, but its origin was, for a moment, a well-kept secret. This is not just Champagne. It is a liquid time capsule of uncompromising elegance. However, do not open it before your booked dinner; it demands, and deserves, to be the dinner itself.
1996 Vintage Report
★★★★★
- Harvest: September 16
- Yield: 10,356 kg/ha
- Vineyard Area: 30,711 ha
- Average potential alcohol: 10.3 %
- Average total acidity: 10.0 g/l
- Average gluconic acid: 0.02 g/l
- Total Sales: 255,871,575 bottles
- France: 160,677,346 bottles
- Export: 95,194,229 bottles
- Indicative price: 24.00 F/kg
Overview: A fantastic year, albeit somewhat controversial. It was hailed early on universally as fantastic both in the region and in the press, and it produced some truly spectacular wines 1. Some observers believe, however, that certain wines either have not lived up to their promise or have reached their peak. I think, however, that the best of these wines are truly exceptional, and some must be counted among the century’s most exceptional efforts.
After a cold spell with temperatures dropping as low as -20°C in some areas during February, the winter was cool but not cold. Bud break occurred from April 20 in most villages. There was hard frost and hail on May 17. The weather was fine in June, except during the flowering period, and Chardonnay suffered particularly from some millerandage. The early growing season was not uniform, with alternating periods of hot and cold, dry and wet. The weather was, however, more cool than hot at the critical moments in the vine’s life: bud break, flowering, and harvest.
The weather stabilized in September, with sunny days and cool nights, which allowed the grapes to continue ripening while preserving their acidity. The harvest began in relatively cool weather. Although there was some rain before the harvest, a strong northerly wind kept the fruit healthy and preserved the acidity. Grey rot of moderate intensity affected on average about 9% of the vineyard, although it was only 3% for Chardonnay. 1996 was also the first year that the level of gluconic acid was measured on a large scale. This compound is produced by the oxidation of aldehydes found in glucose. It usually occurs only in trace amounts in wine made from healthy grapes. It is, however, much more common in grapes affected by botrytis, and it can also form through the action of acetic acid bacteria. For this reason, it was proposed as a marker for the health of the grapes (somewhat technically called their sanitary state).
– According to Champagne Club by Richard Juhlin
1959-2012 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’
Ranking according to Champagne Club by Richard Juhlin
The first score indicates potential score & the second score indicates current score.
- 1959 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent Vinothèque’ 97[97]p
- 1969 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent Vinothèque’ 97[97]p
- 1976 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent Vinothèque’ 97[97]p
- 1964 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 96[96]p
- 1996 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 96[96]p
- 1988 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 95[95]p
- 1990 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 95[95]p
- 1983 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 94[94]p
- 2000 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 94[94]p
- 2002 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 94[89]p
- 1975 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 93[93]p
- 1985 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 93[93]p
- 2008 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 93[90]p
- 1973 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 92[92]p
- 2012 R&L Legras ‘Cuvée Saint-Vincent’ 87[84]p
